How do we write game reviews that provide truly actionable player advice, not just summaries?
In the vast ocean of game reviews, many pieces serve as little more than glorified recaps, detailing plot points, listing features, and perhaps assigning a numerical score. While summaries have their place, they often fall short of truly empowering players. The real challenge, and the true value, lies in moving beyond simple description to provide actionable advice that genuinely helps players decide if a game is for them, and how to best approach it once they dive in.
Shifting Focus: From What to How and For Whom
To write reviews that offer actionable advice, we must first change our perspective. Instead of merely asking “What is this game about?” or “What features does it have?”, we should be asking: “How will playing this game feel for a specific player?” and “Who is this game actually for?” This shift enables us to move from objective observation to subjective, yet practical, guidance.
An actionable review doesn’t just state that a game has a complex crafting system; it advises players on whether that system is intuitive, grind-heavy, or offers meaningful progression, and then suggests strategies for managing it or who might enjoy (or dislike) its intricacies. It contextualizes the experience, making the feedback directly applicable to a player’s potential enjoyment and investment.
Deconstructing Actionable Advice Components
1. Identify the Target Player
No game is for everyone. A truly helpful review identifies the type of player who will thrive (or struggle) with the game. Is it for hardcore strategy enthusiasts, casual narrative lovers, competitive esports aspirants, or solo explorers? By clearly defining the intended audience, you immediately provide a filter for readers.
2. Highlight Key Mechanics and Their Impact
Beyond simply listing mechanics, explain their practical implications. How does the combat system work in actual play? Is it fluid, clunky, demanding, or forgiving? What are the common pitfalls? Offer specific tips: “If you’re struggling with X boss, focus on parries rather than dodges,” or “The economy feels slow initially; prioritize upgrading Y to gain traction.”
3. Manage Expectations and Provide Solutions
Every game has its flaws. Instead of just pointing them out, frame them as challenges to be aware of and, if possible, offer solutions or workarounds. For example, “The UI can be overwhelming at first; spend some time customizing your hotkeys for a smoother experience,” or “Performance issues are notable on older hardware; consider lowering X setting for better frame rates.”
4. Offer Comparative Context
Help players situate the game within the broader landscape. “If you loved the exploration of Elden Ring but wished for more narrative depth, this might be your next obsession,” or “Fans of classic JRPGs will find familiar tropes, but be prepared for a slower pacing than modern titles.” This comparison doesn’t just summarize; it guides based on past player experiences.
Crafting the Actionable Review: Practical Steps
Play Deeply, Not Just Broadly
To offer genuine advice, you need to understand the game intimately. This means not just completing the main story, but experimenting with different builds, exploring side content, engaging with various mechanics, and pushing the game’s boundaries. The deeper your understanding, the more specific and valuable your advice can be.
Empathize with Diverse Player Perspectives
Consider how different players might experience the game. A veteran of the genre will approach it differently than a newcomer. A completionist has different priorities than someone only interested in the story. Tailor sections of your review to address these varied perspectives, providing advice relevant to each.
Structure for Clarity and Accessibility
Use clear headings, bullet points, and an intuitive flow. A “Who Is This Game For?” section, “Tips for New Players,” “Advanced Strategies,” or “Common Pitfalls to Avoid” can significantly enhance the actionable nature of your review. Prioritize the most critical advice upfront.
The Impact of Actionable Reviews
By moving beyond mere summaries, game reviewers become true guides, helping players navigate the complex landscape of gaming. Actionable reviews don’t just tell someone what a game is; they tell them how to engage with it, who it’s best suited for, and what to expect and prepare for. This elevated form of criticism builds trust, fosters a more informed player base, and ultimately leads to more satisfying gaming experiences for everyone.
